| 0 | ||
| Jared "Genghis" Kahn | 2 | something food |
| They call me Bruce | 1 | waistline exploding desert |
| Lucas Kane and Eric Hess | 2 | Double Dragon Roll (not actually bringing sushi) |
| Nathan Johnson | 1 | Power ups |
| B & B Bartley | 2 | Chicken wings |
| Chris Pii and Sara Bii | 2 | Rice Tetris Treats |
| Team Grunks | 4 | Kirby Cake |
| Kathy, Kelly & April | 3 | appetizer |
| Annie & Ralph | 2 | Arroz con Gandule y chorizo |
| dimsdale the game | 1 | mario and luigi glato |
| Steph + Sean | 2 | Will get back to you |
| Mike and Amanda | 2 | Stuffed shells |
| Kristy & Ryan | 2 | stuff |
| Susie Wargo | 1 | |
| Ralph and Kathy Karabec | 3.5 | homemade guacamole and chips |
| Rachel | 1 | Hummus Attack |
| Rachel | 1 | Hummus Attack |
| Cash and Amanda | 2 | Health Potions |
| B&B Thiel | 2 | Super Mario Mushrooms |
| Fran & MIke | 2 | Yoshi's Cookie(s) |
| Lisa & Chris | 2 | ??? |
| Tom & Jill | 2 | Eggplant Rolitini |
| Kyle & Larry | 2 | Side-dish |
| Bill & Pat | 2 | fruit salad |
| The Sileos | 4 | 1 ???? |
| The Kimballs | 2 | Space Pirate Sangria |
| Steven Couture | 1 | Mamma Wanna |
| Bob & Diane | 2 | Dessert |
| Isaac Waldron | 1 | ???? |
| Dave, Kelly & Sam | 3 | sticky bombs (aka buffalo bites) |
| Brookie Bee & Jumpkick | 2 | Super Shrimp Coctail |
| Bill & Iva | 6 | Health Coins (fish & Plantain) |
| Craig & Vanessa | 2 | Pac-Manwiches |
| Chris Sim | 1 | Bowser Brownies |
| Van Wagners | 6 | C.O.D. salad |
| Ryan & Taela | 2 | Luigi pasta |
| Melissa and Lee | 2 | 1 Up Dessert |
| Ben & Lindsey | 2 | Virtual Poi |
| Jeremy and Sara | 2 | NBA Yam |
| Wendy Graef | 1 | Main course |
| Josh Graef & Emma | 2 | Hadouken Ham |
